I want to start this off by saying that Archibald Peck is not "dead." After his match against Eddie Kingston the crowd chanted "You Killed Archie" and Eddie Kingston took credit for doing so, but he did not do this. Instead, he sent Archie back through time. For an answer on what and how that happened, one only need to look at two YouTube videos.
The first explains Archie's timeline. I will attempt to briefly summarize it.
In Archibald Peck's first Chikara match he was Backfisted to the Future by Eddie Kingston. At this time he traveled to the year 2015 and picked up a copy of Chikara's yearbook. When he awoke he was back in 2011, but he remembered what he had read in the book and took advantage of it. The yearbook said that he would win the Young Lions Cup in 2011, but when he didn't time was changed forever. Got that?- At Chikarasaurus Rex in 2012, Mixed Martial Archie (Archibald Peck's tougher alias) teamed with Colt Cabana to take on Mr. Touchdown and Dasher Hatfield in a Loser Leaves Chikara match. During the match Mixed Martial Archie was injured and out from the back came Archibald Peck. At the time everyone assumed that this was merely a costume change for Archie and that Archie was assuming his real persona as Colt Cabana had urged him to do, but after Archie's loss this would turn out not to be the case.
The truth was that Mixed Martial Archie got into a fight backstage with Eddie Kingston (off camera) that sent him back to the year 1885. The Archibald Peck that came to the ring was actually an Archibald Peck from a future date. May 18th to be exact. - A series of videos are produced called "Where in the world is Archibald Peck?" after his loss
- A wrestler named The Mysterious and Handsome Stranger debuts in Chikara. We don't know him, but at Under the Hood he is unmasked to reveal that he is, indeed, Archibald Peck. At this time he is thrown out of the arena because he was not legally allowed to be there after losing a Loser Leaves Town Match. RD Evans explains that this is actually the Mixed Martial Archie that was sent back to the past during the match at Chikarasaurus Rex who then took on the persona of the Mysterious and Handsome Stranger back in the Old West.
- Since Archibald Peck never actually lost the match against in that timeline he was reinstated. However, the Peck who lost that match would be forced to leave Chikara.
- In a conversation with Peck's lawyer RD Evans, Wink says that the "Where In the World is Archibald Peck?" videos were actually of Peck's doppelganger who is still out there somewhere. The doppelganger is then seen going into Parts Unknown.
(With everything in Chikara we can only take the things we are told to be true and go from there, but Wink might actually be an unreliable narrator as he has proven himself to be of lacking intelligence about all things Chikara in the past. The man he called "the doppelganger" could easily be Archibald Peck post-TWGP, but until we have reason to believe this I will stick with only what we have been told as that is the only truth there is in Chikara. They do not lie.) Read More →








